Showing posts with label technology transfer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label technology transfer. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Innovation and Robert Morris University

The huzzahs for tech/higher ed collaboration in Pittsburgh usually emerge from Oakland, home of the rocket scientists at Pitt and CMU. But as most Pittsburghers know, there are many other high caliber colleges and universities in the region. Duquesne, for example, often feels slighted in tech development conversations.

So I was especially intrigued the other day to receive a press release from Robert Morris University that starts off as follows:

Robert Morris University’s Center for Applied Research in Engineering and Science (RMU-CARES) has received two grants from Pittsburgh-based Innovation Works to fund the development of a new manufacturing process and the creation of a device to aid in the care of homebound individuals.

The first grant, for $50,000, is to design and build a robotic work cell for Penna Flame Inc., a Zelienople company that provides flame hardening, a process that renders the surface of machine parts more resistant to wear. Currently, Penna Flame utilizes a manual process in which each tooth of a gear is individually heated with a 2200-degree Fahrenheit flame. As with other manual processes, problems arise with operator fatigue and consistency and quality. The manual operation will be eliminated and replaced by an automated one using industrial robots.

The second grant, for $25,000, will be utilized to design and build three prototypes of a unique device dubbed The Memory Minder. Triggered by a sensor, the device will provide recorded messages in response to the needs of the individual user. The Memory Minder delivers customized messages set by a caretaker, nurse, family
member or the user. The device can deliver several timed messages throughout the day with personalized messages from familiar voices that are critical to an individual’s care.

I hope that I'll be hearing more about RMU's partnering with Innovation Works. The press release came to my in box from longtime Burghosphere contributor and new RMU Director of Public Relations Jonathan Potts, he of The Conversation and the Dead Tree Blog.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

The Real Deal

A long-time friend of Pittsblog wrote me yesterday to suggest this post:

What are the top three entrepreneurial companies in the Pittsburgh region that folks think are the real deal, with job creating potential and wealth creating potential of 100+ jobs and $10M plus in annual revenues?

The 100+ employee threshold and the $10M revenue numbers are arbitrary. What my friend and I are trying to get at, however, is whether folks think (i) that there are more real prospects for sustainable success locally than there were, say, five years ago, and (ii) there are more prospects than ever that can attract and sustain successive rounds of formal and informal private investment -- as opposed to economic development investment via a government-affiliated or subsidized entity.

Post your nominations, justifications, and reservations in the comments. I'm especially interested in hearing from folks in the economic development and investment spaces. Anonymity and pseudonymity are permitted, so long as the comments are on topic and civil.

Tuesday, May 08, 2007

University Tech Transfer

My colleague Mark Lemley, who teaches intellectual property law at Stanford and who is one the country's most innovative thinkers on information law and policy topics, has posted a new manuscript to a website that hosts initial versions of law professors' work product. Unusually for a law review article, Mark's paper is potentially of broad interest to the economic development community and to university tech transfer offices in particular. Here's the title and the relevant portion of the abstract:

"Are Universities Patent Trolls?"

Link to full paper: Stanford Public Law Working Paper No. 980776

The confluence of two significant developments in modern patent practice leads me to write a paper with such a provocative title. The first development is the rise of hold-up as a primary component of patent litigation and patent licensing. The second development in the last three decades is the massive surge in university patenting. At the confluence of these developments is a growing frustration on the part of industry with the role of universities as patent owners. Time and again, when I talk to people in a variety of industries, their view is that universities are the new patent trolls.

In this paper, I argue that Universities should take a broader view of their role in technology transfer. University technology transfer ought to have as its goal maximizing the social impact of technology, not merely maximizing the university's licensing revenue. Sometimes those goals will coincide with the university's short-term financial interests. Sometimes universities will maximize the impact of an invention on society by granting exclusive licenses for substantial revenue to a company that will take the invention and commercialize it. Sometimes, but not always. At other times a non-exclusive license, particularly on a basic enabling technology, will ultimately maximize the invention's impact on society by allowing a large number of people to commercialize in different areas, to try out different things and see if they work, and the like.

University policies might be made more nuanced than simply a choice between exclusive and nonexclusive licenses. For example, they might grant field-specific exclusivity, or exclusivity only for a limited term, or exclusivity only for commercial sales while exempting research, and they might condition continued exclusivity on achievement of certain dissemination goals. Finally, particularly in the software context, there are many circumstances in which the social impact of technology transfer is maximized either by the university not patenting at all or by granting licenses to those patents on a royalty-free basis to all comers.

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Everybody Comes to Rick's

Among the many fabulous lines from Casablanca is Rick Blaine's comment to Major Strasser. Strasser wants to impress on Rick that the Germans know everything about him; Rick, reading the dossier himself, asks the Major, "Are my eyes really brown?"

I flew on USAirways over the weekend and had an "are my eyes really brown" moment reading the Profile of Pittsburgh that appears in the current (March 2007) in-flight magazine. The whole thing is a masterful piece of marketing by the Allegheny Conference, the Pittburgh Technology Council, and the Mayor's Office. The city and region have rarely been shown off to such wonderful advantage. Still, reading some of the descriptions of the city, I wondered about the region's self-description much as Rick Blaine wondered about the color of his eyes.

Some interesting, and representative, quotations:

"The economic development climate in Pittsburgh has gone from hot to one fire," adds Mayor Luke Ravenstahl . . . .

"VisitPittsburgh President and CEO Joe McGrath says, "There's tremendous momentum in Pittsburgh right now, and that message is being heard across the globe -- how the city continues to develop, creating an environment that's great for business and families alike."

"[T]he region's economics are both strong and diversified," says Allegheny Conference's [CEO Mike] Langley . . . ."

"With the role they've played in past renaissances," Ravenstahl says, "we know we can rely on the Allegheny Conference for the revolutionary advances we'll make in twentieth-century Pittsburgh."

[Referring to the Life Sciences Greenhouse, Innovation Works, and the Technology Collaborative] "This is the kind of help that technology receives in Pittsburgh," [PITC CEO Steve] Zylstra says. "It is unprecedented -- and unmatched."

"Where else could innovators and entrepreneurs be in the midst of both corporate and university research centers, live affordably near where they work, and have access to world-class culture and outdoor recreation?" wonders Future Strategies President Harold Miller. "No wonder people never want to leave."


I don't want to be too hard on well-intentioned, meaningless puffery, since it's always nice to see Pittsburgh look good. Criticizing Luke Ravenstahl for praising the "revolutionary advances" he anticipates from the Allegheny Conference would be like Lucy pulling the football away from Charlie Brown. Lucy loses that confrontation; we pity Charlie Brown.

But do people really never want to leave? Didn't the Commonwealth just agree to pay Mario Lemieux $10.5 million to stay?

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Best Practices in Tech Transfer

[cross-posted from madisonian.net]:

Licensing directors at 11 leading American research universities have released “In the Public Interest: Nine Points to Consider in Licensing University Technology,” a best-practices-style white paper summary of strategies for university-based technology transfer. The points are:

Point 1
Universities should reserve the right to practice licensed inventions
and to allow other non-profit and governmental organizations to do so

Point 2
Exclusive licenses should be structured in a manner that encourages technology development and use

Point 3
Strive to minimize the licensing of “future improvements”

Point 4
Universities should anticipate and help to manage technology transfer related conflicts of interest

Point 5
Ensure broad access to research tools

Point 6
Enforcement action should be carefully considered

Point 7
Be mindful of export regulations

Point 8
Be mindful of the implications of working with patent aggregators

Point 9
Consider including provisions that address unmet needs, such as those of neglected patient populations or geographic areas, giving particular attention to improved therapeutics, diagnostics and agricultural technologies for the developing world

Link: http://news-service.stanford.edu/news/2007/march7/gifs/whitepaper.pdf

Will Pitt and CMU sign on?